I'll admit it: PocketGuard solved my problem perfectly. For about six months.
I was the kind of person who would check my bank balance, see $2,000, and think "great, I can buy that thing I've been eyeing." Then my rent would auto-pay, my car insurance would hit, and suddenly I was scrambling to cover groceries until payday.
PocketGuard's 'In My Pocket' feature fixed that immediately. It showed me what I could actually spend after accounting for bills and savings goals. It was like putting on glasses for the first time.
But here's the thing about simplicity: it cuts both ways.
The Day I Outgrew PocketGuard
It happened when I wanted to do something that felt simple: track how much I was spending on food delivery versus grocery shopping. My DoorDash habit had gotten out of control during work-from-home, and I wanted to see the damage.
PocketGuard had categorized all my DoorDash orders, sure. But I couldn't:
- See a trend over the past 6 months
- Compare delivery vs. groceries month-over-month in a custom chart
- Create a visualization I could actually share with my partner
- Export the data to do my own analysis in a spreadsheet
PocketGuard's response to all of this was essentially: "that's not what we do."
And honestly? Fair enough. But I needed more.
What PocketGuard Actually Does Well
Before I go further, let me give credit where it's due. PocketGuard genuinely excels at a few things:
The 'In My Pocket' Feature
Genuinely brilliant. Shows you what you can actually spend after bills and goals. Simple, visual, and solves a real problem that most apps ignore.
Zero Setup Required
Download the app, connect your banks, and you're done. No spreadsheets to configure, no formulas to write. It just works out of the box.
Clean, Simple Interface
The app is genuinely pleasant to use. No clutter, no overwhelming features. Perfect for a quick financial check-in.
Generous Free Tier
The free version is actually usable. You get the core 'In My Pocket' feature without paying anything. Many competitors lock everything behind paywalls.
Bill Tracking Built In
Automatically detects recurring bills and factors them into your spendable amount. No manual entry needed.
If those features are all you need, PocketGuard is genuinely a great choice. I used it happily for months.
But here's where it falls apart...
The Real Cost of 'Simple'
PocketGuard's simplicity is a feature, not a bug. For a lot of people, it's exactly right. But for others - especially those of us who like to understand our money, not just glance at it - that simplicity becomes a straitjacket.
Here's what finally pushed me to look for a PocketGuard alternative:
- I was paying $7.99/month for PocketGuard Plus and still couldn't customize anything meaningful
- My financial data was trapped in their app with barely any export options
- I was already using Google Sheets for other financial planning - why maintain two separate systems?
- Every time I wanted to analyze something specific, I had to start from scratch manually
- No investment tracking beyond basic balance - I wanted to see my full portfolio
PocketGuard vs BankSync: Complete Feature Comparison
Let me give you the honest comparison. No marketing spin - just what each tool actually does:
PocketGuard vs BankSync Feature Comparison
| Feature |
|---|
Pricing Breakdown: What You Actually Pay
Let's talk money, since that's literally what we're here for:
Pricing Comparison
PocketGuard vs BankSync costs over time
PocketGuard Free
Basic spendable cash tracking
- 'In My Pocket' calculation
- Bank account connections
- Basic categorization
- 3 months transaction history
- Custom categories
- Data export
- Ad-free experience
PocketGuard Plus
Enhanced features, still limited
- Everything in Free
- Unlimited transaction history
- Custom categories
- Debt payoff planning
- Cash flow calendar
- No ads
- Custom dashboards
- Third-party integrations
BankSync
Unlimited flexibility in your tools
- Unlimited bank connections
- Notion, Sheets, Airtable sync
- Build ANY dashboard you want
- Full transaction history
- Investment tracking
- Custom categorization
- Automated syncing
- 14-day free trial
Where Your Data Actually Goes
One of the biggest differences between PocketGuard and BankSync is where your financial data lives:
Sync Your Bank Data To
Notion
Build financial dashboards alongside your life planning. Create linked databases for transactions, accounts, and budgets. Perfect for the all-in-one workspace crowd.
Google Sheets
Full spreadsheet power with automatic transaction imports. Create any formula, chart, or analysis you can imagine. Familiar interface, unlimited possibilities.
Airtable
Database-powered budgeting with automations. Set up triggers, create custom views, and build workflows that manage your money automatically.
With PocketGuard, your data lives in their app. Period. You can look at it through their interface, but you can't really do anything with it beyond what they've built.
With BankSync, your data syncs to tools you already know and use. Want to build a custom 'In My Pocket' formula? Do it. Want to create a 12-month spending trend chart? Easy. Want to set up automations that alert you when spending exceeds a threshold? Go for it.
Building Your Own 'In My Pocket' (It's Easier Than You Think)
When I switched to BankSync, my biggest concern was losing that simple "what can I spend" number. Turns out, it took me about 20 minutes to build my own version in Google Sheets - and it's actually better than PocketGuard's because I customized the logic to match how I actually think about money.
Here's the formula I use:
In Notion, you can use rollups and formulas to create real-time calculations that update automatically as BankSync imports new transactions. In Airtable, you can even set up automations that notify you when your spendable amount drops below a threshold.
Who Should Stick with PocketGuard?
I'll be honest - PocketGuard is genuinely the better choice for some people:
You just want to know what you can spend
If the 'In My Pocket' number is genuinely all you need, PocketGuard does this better out of the box than anything else.
You hate spreadsheets and databases
If the thought of setting up formulas makes you want to close this tab, PocketGuard's zero-setup approach is probably better for you.
You primarily use your phone for finances
PocketGuard's mobile app is genuinely excellent. BankSync is more powerful but web-focused.
You don't already use Notion, Sheets, or Airtable
If you'd have to learn a new tool anyway, the simplicity of PocketGuard might be worth the trade-off.
You want free forever
PocketGuard's free tier is genuinely usable. BankSync has a trial but requires subscription for ongoing use.
Who Should Switch to BankSync?
BankSync makes more sense if you're looking for something PocketGuard can't provide:
You Already Use Notion/Sheets/Airtable
Why maintain two systems? Get your bank data flowing into tools you already love and use daily.
You Want Custom Analysis
Build any report, chart, or dashboard you can imagine. Compare categories over time, track trends, create projections.
You Want Automation
Set up rules that categorize transactions, alert you to unusual spending, or update budgets automatically.
You Track Investments
Full portfolio sync including individual holdings and trades - not just account balances.
You Care About Data Ownership
Your data lives in your Notion workspace, your Google account, your Airtable base. You control it completely.
You Share Finances with Others
Easily share dashboards with partners, accountants, or financial advisors using tools they already know.
You're a Power User
If you've ever wished PocketGuard could do 'just one more thing,' BankSync can do that thing.
You Enjoy Building Systems
If optimizing your personal finance workflow sounds fun rather than tedious, you'll love BankSync.
What Real Users Say
"I used PocketGuard for over a year and loved the simplicity. But when I wanted to track my side hustle income separately and create monthly reports for tax purposes, I hit a wall. BankSync let me build exactly what I needed in Google Sheets. Now I have my 'spendable cash' number AND custom reports for my business - all updating automatically."
Frequently Asked Questions
The Bottom Line
PocketGuard does one thing really, really well: showing you what you can spend. The 'In My Pocket' feature is genuinely brilliant, and if that's all you need from a finance app, it's a great choice.
But the moment you want to ask "what else?" - that's when its simplicity becomes a limitation. BankSync gives you the same bank syncing capability with the power to answer any financial question you can think of.
For me, the switch was a no-brainer. Now I have my 'In My Pocket' number and detailed spending analysis and investment tracking and custom automations - all in the tools I already use every day.
If you're the kind of person who reads blog posts comparing budgeting tools, you're probably ready for something more powerful than PocketGuard. Give BankSync a try - you might be surprised how quickly you build something better than what you had.
No credit card required. Cancel anytime. Your data stays in your tools even if you stop using BankSync.